WASHINGTON (NYTIMES) – Dr Scott Atlas has argued that the science of mask wearing is uncertain, that children cannot pass on the coronavirus and that the role of the government is not to stamp out the virus but to protect its most vulnerable citizens as Covid-19 takes its course.
Ideas like these, both ideologically freighted and scientifically disputed, have propelled the radiologist and senior fellow at Stanford University’s conservative Hoover Institution into US President Donald Trump’s White House, where he is pushing to reshape the administration’s response to the pandemic.
Mr Trump has embraced Dr Atlas, as has Mr Mark Meadows, the White House chief of staff, even as he upsets the balance of power within the White House coronavirus task force with ideas that top government doctors and scientists like Dr Anthony Fauci, Dr Deborah Birx and Dr Jerome Adams, the surgeon-general, find misguided – even dangerous – according to people familiar with the task force’s deliberations.
That might be the point.
“I think Trump clearly does not like the advice he was receiving from the people who are the experts – Fauci, Birx, etc – so he has slowly shifted from their advice to somebody who tells him what he wants to hear,” said Dr Carlos del Rio, an infectious disease expert at Emory University who is close to Dr Birx, the White House coronavirus response coordinator.
Dr Atlas is neither an epidemiologist nor an infectious disease expert, the two jobs usually associated with pandemic response. But his frequent appearances on Fox News Channel and his ideological surety caught the President’s eye.
So when Mr Trump resumed his coronavirus news conferences in July and August, it was Dr Atlas who helped prepare his briefing materials, according to people familiar with them. And it was his ideas that spilled from the President’s mouth.
“He has many great ideas,” Mr Trump told reporters at a White House briefing last month with Dr Atlas seated metres away. “And he thinks what we’ve done is really good, and now we’ll take it to a new level.”
The core of his appeal in the West Wing rests in his libertarian-style approach to disease management in which the government focuses on small populations of at-risk individuals – the elderly, the sick and the immune-compromised – and minimises restrictions for the rest of the population, akin to an approach used to disastrous effect in Sweden.
The argument: Most people infected by the coronavirus will not get seriously ill, and at some point, enough people will have antibodies from Covid-19 to deprive the virus of carriers – “herd immunity”.
“Once you get to a certain number – we use the word herd – once you get to a certain number, it’s going to go away,” Mr Trump told Ms Laura Ingraham on Fox News on Monday night (Aug 31).
Dr Atlas’ push has led to repeated private confrontations with Dr Birx, who in recent weeks has been advocating rigorous rules on wearing masks, limiting bars and restaurants, and minimising large public gatherings.
Dr Atlas declined a request to be interviewed, but Mr Judd Deere, a White House spokesman, accused the news media of trying to “distort and diminish” his beliefs and record, adding that the adviser “is working to carry out the President’s No. 1 priority: protecting the health and safety of the American people.”
White House officials said there had never been an attempt to shift policy to anything resembling herd immunity.
“There’s never been any advocacy of a herd immunity strategy coming from me to the president, to anyone in the administration, to the task force, to anyone I’ve spoken to,” Dr Atlas said in a radio interview on Tuesday.
White House officials said administration policy continued to focus on efforts to curb the spread of the disease while pushing to rapidly develop medical therapies to minimise deaths, as well as a vaccine. The president and his aides believe effective treatments are critical to allowing the country to return to normal.
But health officials say Dr Atlas’ beliefs, argued in news media appearances and private conversations, have begun to shift the administration’s thinking.
Before joining the task force, Dr Atlas pitched his ideas as a health commentator on Fox News, which is in part how he attracted Mr Trump’s attention. His arrival at the White House has coincided with less visible roles for Dr Birx and Dr Fauci, the director of the National Institute for Allergy and Infectious Diseases.
Dr Atlas pushed for the Centres for Disease Control and Prevention to publish a new recommendation last week that people without Covid-19 symptoms need not be tested, even if they were exposed to an infected person – a move that ran counter to evidence that people without symptoms could be the most prolific spreaders.
In a tense coronavirus task force meeting in which the guidelines were debated, Dr Atlas angered Dr Robert Redfield, the CDC director, and Dr Birx, according to senior administration officials.
But it is Dr Atlas’ embrace of herd immunity that has alienated his colleagues the most.
“When you isolate everyone, including all the healthy people, you’re prolonging the problem because you’re preventing population immunity,” Dr Atlas said in a Fox News radio interview in July. “Low-risk groups getting the infection is not a problem. In fact, it’s a positive.”
In a Fox News interview in June, he lamented that “misinformation has spread” about herd immunity, arguing: “The reality is that when a population has enough people who have had the infection, and since these people don’t have a problem with the infection, that’s not a problem. That’s not a bad thing.”
Mr Kevin Hassett, a former chairman of Trump’s Council of Economic Advisers, who returned briefly to the White House this spring to help with the response to the pandemic, called Dr Atlas “a legendary physician, and one of the smartest guys I know”.
He cited Dr Atlas’ early warnings for governors to protect nursing homes from the virus. “He’s very similar to President Trump, in that you never have to wonder what he thinks,” Mr Hassett said.
Mr Trump is clearly enamoured with Dr Atlas’ arguments, which back up the President’s desire to restart the economy, open schools and move beyond the daily drumbeat of dire virus news.
But fully embracing any version of a policy resembling herd immunity has profound medical and political risks. Simply allowing the virus to travel through most of the population could lead to hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of deaths. And medical officials are still not sure how long that immunity might last, and how long-lasting some effects of the virus could be.
“Trying to get to herd immunity other than with a vaccine isn’t a strategy,” said Dr Tom Frieden, a former CDC director. “It’s a catastrophe.”
In Washington, Dr Atlas has introduced new tension to the coronavirus task force.
In one of his first meetings, he argued over the science of mask wearing. As Dr Fauci and Dr Birx maintained that drops in caseloads reflected public health measures such as social distancing and mask-wearing, Dr Atlas insisted that peaks and declines could have merely been the virus running its course, senior administration officials said.
In other discussions, he argued that children cannot spread the virus, despite numerous studies that have shown that children can carry the virus, transmit it and die from it.
In a June interview with the Hoover Institution, he called it “literally irrational” to close schools. “All over the world, Switzerland, Iceland, Australia, the United Kingdom, Ireland, Asian countries, there is a minimal, if any, risk of children transmitting the disease, even to their parents,” he said.
Dr Atlas brought a similar argument to an August event encouraging school reopenings with Mr Trump and Ms Betsy DeVos, the education secretary.
His role in the White House has given conservative media a new official to present as a scientific authority on the coronavirus.
“The reality is that there’s certain data that’s very controversial about masks,” he told Mr Tucker Carlson, the Fox News host, in August, railing against the “massive amount of fear bordering on hysteria”.
Dr Atlas has also regularly promoted an idea that immunologists say is simply wrong, that immune cells called T-cells, programmed with infection from other coronaviruses, can function like antibodies to prevent Covid-19.
Source: Read Full Article